An employment tribunal struck out former Jaguar Land Rover head of overseas HR Mr Baker’s claims after his ill health and delays meant a fair trial could not be completed within the time available. The ruling did not determine the merits of his allegations against the company.
Baker had brought claims including disability discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments, whistleblowing detriment, unfair dismissal and breach of contract. He alleged bullying, threats and victimisation, and said JLR had not properly investigated his grievances. These were allegations, not findings established by the tribunal.
Health and hearing adjustments
Baker told the company he had chronic pain, PTSD, anxiety and depression. He went on sick leave in September 2023 and resigned in May 2025. The hearing was delayed several times. Adjustments included regular breaks, extra time to answer questions and access to a quiet private space.
During cross-examination, Baker became unwell. His psychiatrist later reported that the questioning had intensified his PTSD symptoms and requested that questions be provided in advance. Cross-examination resumed with breaks and topics supplied beforehand, but the tribunal was told that Baker was experiencing intense anxiety and felt the questioning was hostile.
Reason for the decision
JLR applied to strike out the claim, arguing that the lost hearing time and applications by both sides meant a fair trial was no longer possible. Employment Judge Hilary Harding accepted the application. She said the time already lost, together with the time needed to deal with the applications, made a fair trial impossible within the available hearing fixture.
Original Source: https://www.personneltoday.com/hr/baker-jaguar-land-rover-strike-out/








